Here's a tale of horrors of #pragma pack. I already posted quite a bit about the issue over on that thread at GameDev.Net, so I won't bother reposting it here. It's an interesting read into solving a particular, very strange, bug.
The gist of the issue was that I forgot to disable a particular #pragma pack in one of my headers - causing the packing rules to propogate down into the FCollada header files. Because of this, the compiler got the padding and offsets wrong, which resulted in corrupted this pointers all over the place.
It was, by far, my most harrowing debugging experience. However, it was an experience not to be forgotten. And it was an excellent showcase for Visual Studio's amazing debugging capabilities. I'm not kidding here; Visual Studio has the best and easiest to use debugger ever. Period. I really doubt I could have resolved this bug without the awesome debugger in VS.
But, my crashing problems were still not resolved. Even after I fixed that rogue #pragma pack, the code ran fine in Debug mode. But crashed in Release mode. Since I couldn't really use the debugger in release mode, I had no idea what was going on. The capabilities of the debugger are castrated in release mode, since release mode is supposed to be for final production-level code, and has no debugging facilities.
All I knew was that the crash was occurring even before WinMain() was hit. Which meant that something funky was going on. The debugger did still help, even though was in release mode. The code that was causing the crash was a static variable in one of FCollada's classes: a tree class of some sort.
A quick look at the code in the tree class revealed this little fact: the constructor of the tree class allocated some memory through a global memory handler. The global memory handler was just a global variable, a function pointer, that was initialised to malloc/free. Whenever an allocation was made, this function pointer would be used to allocate memory.
Experienced programmers should see the bug. It's a very subtle way to crash your program, and is difficult to track down. It's known as the Static Initialisation Order Fiasco. Global variables do not have a defined order of initialisation in C++ - it all depends on how the compiler was feeling that day. In other words, initialisation order is effectively random.
So what was actually happening? Well, the global tree variable was being initialised before the memory manager was. That meant that in the constructor for the tree, it was trying to allocate some memory. But since the memory manager hadn't even been initialised yet, the entire program crashed before it had even hit main()!
Up to this point, everyone had just gotten lucky. The compiler had, for some reason, decided to always intitialise the memory manager first. So the memory manager was initialised and ready to go by the time the tree was constructed. But when I recompiled the code, my compiler decided to do it in the reverse order which crashed the program with a difficult-to-detect bug.
This is one of the things that makes globals so damn dangerous - the static initialisation order fiasco gives your program a 50/50 percent chance of dying. And it's random. As the C++ FAQ Lite deftly noted, it's like playing russian roulette with half the chambers loaded.
Needless to say, I left a post informing the developers about it and posted a fix. FCollada is no longer managed by Feeling Software; they relegated the responsibility to the open source community. It remains to be seen whether they'll actually fix this bug, but I'm not hopeful. In the meantime, I've fixed the bug on my local copy of the source code, and now my COLLADA loader is working fine.
Stay tuned for next time: Optimising the mesh loader.
Wednesday, April 2, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comments:
Whoa! this blog is quite something. I've been reading this since yesterday, and frankly, your blog interests me. THe level of your information is highly commendable and most importantly, your findings were well elaborated. I would appreciate it alot if you were to list your system specifications and software used for this 3d engine. Thanks for your time.
Post a Comment